to be honest we throw a little of everything, the water temp right now is anywhere from 68 to 83 degrees depending on where you are at on the lake, we prefished the other day and threw 8 different baits and rigs and caught fish, i know i can put 5 in boat fast on rattle trap, but everything else we throw we catch same size fish, the lake might only have small fish in it, been like this for about as long as i can remember, they introduced shad 5 years ago and the fish started getting bigger but 2 years later there was no shad, water temp to high to spawn and the fish got them up in the coolest cove of lake and basically wiped them out according to DNR