That is why I said 100% guarantee since I do not have time to waste on my vacations. So far I have had 100% success rate in catching nice fish in my vacations up north with my better half. I do very well in South Florida and can give a 100% guarantee that I can take someone fishing me and they will catch lots of fish such as peacock bass, snook, various species of shark, and other fish that people pay hundreds of dollars to guides to catch. Would not be fair to ice fish and not catch much while I take someone fishing with me and they break new PB's for various species of fish so I expect a very good ice fishing trip in return. That 45.5 inch pike must of been fun to catch! I caught a similar sized muskie from public waters on my first trip up north and it is an experience I will always remember.
I am sure open water fishing is much more fun just like snook fishing is more fun than bass fishing but it is always good to try new types of fishing. It makes you a more well rounded fisherman than someone who only fishes for bass. I enjoy challenges and ice fishing has been on my bucket list for many years now so I will do it for sure in a future vacation. This is a bass forum but many bass fishermen also do multi species fishing I am sure there are plenty of bass fishermen that enjoy ice fishing for other species of fish.