I do not think you understand something about the way the warranties work. All of the manufacturers have an initial warranty that covers rods if they have defects in them. So if you bought that Dobyns rod and it just broke in half almost right away (within the specified time) they would replace it free. After that or even during that if you broke it by slamming the car door on it, a bear ate half of it, they do not care how it breaks the replacement policy is for you to pay a specified amount based on the retail price. That cost, to you, covers their expense to make and supply you with another rod. Think of it this way if you buy a car and during the warranty period you maintain it correctly but the engine blows up at 10,000 miles, you expect their warranty will cover the repair. The factory will not pay for your engine to be repaired if you drove it with no oil in it. This is sorta the same. Dobyns Fury rods are good quality rods for an economical price. You can pay about half the price and get it replaced. Also check with a Dobyns dealer near you. Often you do not have to order it and ship it from the factory, the dealer may do it right in the store.
I have had two rods break in my lifetime. Both of them were G Loomis rods. I had to go to my local dealer and the store did the exchange. I do not blame G Loomis, they build quality rods, both times the rods broke because of something that happened while the rods were not in use but sitting on my boat's deck.
It sound like flipping the fish onto land caused it to break, perhaps it had been accidentally damaged by a quick hit on a boat deck or something else and today the graphite just let go under stress. If you liked the rod, its size, its action, and taper but would like a more sensitive rod then ask to pay the upgrade to a Sierra or Champion series. Get the same model rod in the higher end series. I did just that with one of my G Loomis's. I had a 6 foot SJR-721 IM6 that I loved. It broke, my fault not theirs, so I went to my local dealer and found the newer model. Unfortunately it had changed to an uplocking reel seat which i hated. I paid something like $50 for a replacement and $40 to upgrade to an IMX version. I am glad I did.
You say why not get a rod with a carefree warranty, the other rods will have the same type of warranty. Sorry. No free lunch.
By the way I have had several of the new Doyns Sierras in my hand, they are nice, so are the G Loomis E6 and the ST Croix, but do not expect any of the manufacturer's to give free rods away if a factory defect is not the cause of the breakage. If you believe the rod broke due to a manufacturer's defect, and you believe it is still under warranty you can call and make arrangement to ship it back in for inspection. I would not bother myself. Your choice of course