Before fishing I was into mid range target shooting and with it there were things that mattered a lot at all levels, like a consistent trigger pull, and things that only mattered once you were very very skilled, like checking each bullet for roundness. I suspect fishing is the same way, but I don't yet have a sense of what category things fall into.
While I do very much believe you that experience does trump all, but I really notice a huge difference between a Lews BB1 with a centrifugal brake and a Lews LFS with a magnetic. For a while I had them on the same rod with almost identical line and it was really night and day. Obviously one is a more expensive reel then the other, but even my nicer Daiwa reels I struggle to pitch with, even using a wide range of lure weights to try and find a sweet spot.
While I know I do need to practice more, I would like to get a reel that makes it as easy to learn as possible. Also I am now seeing that "For enthusiasts, technique specific gear is fun to collect" thing that gets posted a lot happening to me.
EDIT: I want to make sure that I am not coming off dismissive of your vastly greater experience, but I am only trying to put some information to the results I am seeing with different reels with similar rods, lines, and lures.