I hate to admit it but at one point in my life I managed a shoe store. So when it comes to shoes, I'd like to think I know a few things and one of them is, everyones feet are different. Also, your feet are different at different times in your life. For most people that means even having your feet change as the day goes on. Your feet swell and sweat throughout the day. So what does that mean, most people don't were the correct shoes and you may have a hard time finding shoes that are perfect for your feet, even from most name brands.
A couple things that are hard to get into peoples' heads are... shoes sizes are not universal and soft, "comfortable shoes" (Hokas, heavy cushioned running shoes, Crocs, for example) are usually the worst thing for your feet. Another is don't wear the same pair of shoes everyday. Sounds weird but most vulcanized shoes take 24-48 hours to reform and have the sweat from your feet evaporate after you wear them. Letting a pair sit for a day will get the shoe to last longer and allow it to form better to your foot making better for your feet.
From my powerlifting days....These two images below illustrate what I am talking about when it comes to bad/proper fitting shoes for day to day wear. Even though they are meant to illustrate why squatting in the wrong shoes can be bad, the same principle applies to standing all day.
So what shoes do I recommend..... For some, this is like recommending fishing line, it can get personal and rightfully so. I would find a good shoe store or even a podiatrist to look at your feet and get their input. Be prepared for a reality check.
For me for fishing, I have tried all kinds of shoes over the years. The Keen Solrs I have been using this year have been great. But prior to that, I was using Teva Strata sandals. Both shoes give/adjust to how my feet swell and are comfortable all day. When it's colder, I use hiking boots from Asolo. For everyday, I like the Oboz Sawtooth. The insoles are fantastic, as they form to your feet. For a comfortable indulgence (aka grilling, sitting around and drinking beer) I like sandals and slippers from OluKai. For working out, I like the Nike Metacon and if I am serious about some heavy lifts, the Adidas Adipower. Running shoes... never going to happen, see pic above.