Jump to content

Neil McCauley

Members
  • Posts

    414
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Neil McCauley

  1. I tend to let the lure do the action for crankbaits, though I will try a stop and go if they are reluctant to bite. I try to limit deflection and bottom-contact because it beats up the lip and they don't cast/dive as well with lots of scratches. I've also lost a few baits this way, and not just getting stuck between rocks or in logs- one of my more heavily used Rapala DT-16s last year actually completely disconnected from the lip on a cast, the epoxy holding it on just gave way. For me the key with crankbaits is maximizing the bait's time at target depth. Like someone pointed out, roughly 1/3rd of the retrieve is spent descending to that depth, another 1/3rd spend ascending from that depth. You can increase that middle 1/3rd where the bait is in the target zone two ways, either increasing the distance covered by the retrieve or increasing the rate at which the bait dives. Cast further by using lower test softer line, which also helps with diving. But you can also cover more distance using wind to your advantage. Obviously casting with the wind is one, but you have to make sure that you're anchored and not drifting toward the bait you're reeling in which is a waste of the longer distance cast. I will do this when I have a specific isolated structure I'm targeting like a sunken hump. The alternative is if you have a bait that casts really well into the wind, you can do that while allowing the boat to drift away from your cast direction, retrieving slightly slower to compensate for the drift speed, sort of semi-trolling. I like this when I'm drifting along a long linear structure like a drop-off along a shoreline. When I'm using CBs as search baits casting distance is important enough to me that I'll go back to monofilament line instead of fluoro for the extra distance it gives.
  2. Really can't ask for better weather.
  3. I'll be out there this weekend. Not yet after bass though, lakers and salmon for now. Gonna be great to be back on the water.
  4. Did 2 back to back full day trips last April and got skunked. ~8 hrs each straight with no catch, it was like the lake had no fish. Think the water was just too cold and I had never fished cold water. Was very discouraged, but then 2 weeks later I couldn't keep them off my line.
  5. Bump, no one fishing for Lake Trout? Bueller?
  6. this is ridiculous
  7. Whatever you think is worthwhile, I'm still new to sonar.
  8. I've only have a little PiranhaMax 197c with a 28 deg sonar cone the past few months but mostly it seems helpful for identifying cover and baitfish, letting you know a spot isn't dead. Trolling crankbaits still seems more efficient at "finding fish" imo, esp if you can follow contour lines. I would be much more lost without Navionics. That changed fishing for me almost as adding a motor to my canoe.
  9. Anyone have experience with these? Could they charge a big 27 or 29 group 12v marine battery?
  10. By North, do you mean Northern Basin? It is a bit different from the Southern Basin. A lot less boat traffic, probably fishing pressure also. Never fished it, to be honest. You really can't go wrong fishing LG for bass any time in June. The smallmouth bite does slow a bit later in the month, but the LMB stays hot. Submerged weedbeds and humps in 15-30 fow, around 8-9PM fishing a shallow running crankbait over these places is usually absurd. Deeper humps 30-40' you can catch fish any time of day. The only downside imo is this time of year the smaller 8-12" bass really get active and will hit any lure you use, and you won't get any fish in the 18"+ range. My solution is fish deeper with bigger baits.
  11. The extremes of success- red hot bite or completely dead. There is actually a good statistical rationale for this: there is good positive predictive value (or negative predictive value) for a lure being very effective or very ineffective depending on the "pre-test probability" ie how easy the fish are to catch at that point. For example, if the fish are biting everything, and you throw something and it fails miserably, you can be very sure it is a terrible presentation, at least in those conditions and that location, time of year, etc. On the other hand, if it is a dead bite and you find something that is effective, this again is very predictive of a successful presentation for those conditions in the future. Use your bread and butter techniques and apply your basic fundamentals when the fishing is average. At the extremes- when it sucks or it is crazy good, that is when it pays off to get creative, at least for the sake of your learning.
  12. First off. Sell the kayak. Buy the canoe. That said, yes, I generally have a plan. That plan is usually made a few months or so in advance according to the time of year, and refined a week ahead according to the weather conditions. That plan is usually based ona a species and then a general presentation. I will target pumpkinseeds with worms, or bass casting crankbaits, or perch jigging, pike trolling swimbaits, etc... The weather the week before makes a big difference. The day-of, I will stick with the plan unless it seems to be absolutely failing. Your definition of absolute failure may be up to you to decide. Personally it means no fish in the first 2 hours. At that point I switch to a backup plan. At some point my back up plan always seems to be jigging for perch or pumpkinseeds. Hence why I take a couple dozen nightcrawlers almost ever trip in the summer. I think the key to success is not just having a plan but having one that has been battle tested and proven by yourself in the past. New anglers obviously do not have this luxury. I guess that's the fun of it and the challenge. Eventually you will have a plan and slew of backup plans for every time of year and every condition that could possibly pop up therein. Not many of us reach that point though.
  13. More traditional sonar images please if anyone has em.
  14. What water temps are people seeing on the larger lakes right now? LG was 36-38 about 2 weeks ago.
  15. 6.25"....2.5 oz. what a beast
  16. This is one of the few times of the year lakers aren't 200 ft deep and can be caught on light tackle. So...what tackle to actually use? Troll spoons and plugs?
  17. Most big Northeast lakes are thawed already.. I am not used to open water this time of year, water temps are 36-38F. When should fishing start to pick up?
  18. It IS enormous... 6-7" Rapala Super Shad. Pike like it.
  19. Tried it out today! First time using a fish finder. Didn't find much. Water temp was 38 deg though.
  20. Obviously, but if someone could explain exactly why it is that would be helpful.
  21. It's hard to find evidence for everything, particularly evidence of an intervention making a difference. Comparatively pretty easy to show it makes "no difference" because of how statistical analyses are done and how many practical limitations research has. In my line of work for example lots of drug companies like to site research demonstrating their medication as "non-inferior" to the current alternatives. But typically when they say that I don't care, does it also make sense? If not then I really don't care. With bed fishing the data does not make sense and the studies showing it are not that large. I am not surprised they "fail to show" that bed fishing harms fish populations. I still don't do it, at least not intentionally. Pulling a spawning fish temporarily off its bed and stressing it when it is not eating and is focusing its energy 100% on reproduction is logically going to impair its success at that activity.
  22. Big deep diving crankbaits for me. Everything else a distant second and I don't use them enough to tell the difference. Rapala sitter pops have worked well for me May-June, not much after that.
  23. Everyone seems to agree that deep cycle 12v batteries should be stored fully charged. But then for lithium computer or phone batteries it's only at 50%. Not sure why the difference.
  24. Canoe keeps you further from the water, handles waves and spray better. But yea, if it rains, it rains. If you really want to be a madman you can get a spray skirt:
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.