they both have their place in your arsenal.you can't say one or the other.to start i would buy a 3/8 white double willow spinnerbait.a 3/8 black single colorado spinnerbait.a 1/2 oz.rattlin rapala in shad pattern.a set of 3 crank baits in shad pattern.1 shallow,1 medium(8ft) and 1 deep(14 ft). you can take it from there but that would get you started.