I can attest to this, living in Northwest Indiana. Though, on the other hand, you have to consider that most fishermen, Amish included, aren't good fishermen. A lot of people go out with live bait and when they don't catch anything they say "Oh well, the fish just aren't biting!". It took me a while to change from that attitude to an attitude of "Well, they aren't biting on this presentation.. But they will on something else.."