I don't know. It's always been my belief that if the fish are hungry, that just about any lure will work if presented to them correctly. That said, most other baits, other than a worm, are easier/quicker to present to the fish in colder water
I caught two large mouths yesterday fishing an out side point/wall. I was using a split shot, purple worm. They were on the small side (2 lbs?) but they still ate the bait. Water temp was 50*F, and the fish were in 30' +/- of water. They were the only fish I caught in 3 hours of fooling around.
Out west there use to be a guy who could catch LM bass in very deep water, in the winter, with a worm technique he called "doodling". It was a pain staking, time consuming way to fish, but it worked.
Me personally, I am a top water junkie. The only fish I can catch in the winter on a TW bait are stripers, and even then, those fish need to be out of their normal winter haunts.