Sounds about right. I let a friend borrow one of my setups. The reel was a righty and he throws with his left hand on the reel. He had a few horrible birds nests that made me cringe from the grinding, clanging noises and that's when I noticed he was casting with the reel horizontal. So the handle was moving and engaging the spool mid cast! Later, when I got home I noticed that he had the spool tension pretty tight and was having to really snap the casts to get any distance. Lesson learned!