Today I had a discussion with an older man in my church who spent a lot of his life fishing tournament trails across the country, including co-angling for a long time in FLW. He was talking to me about not wasting money on buying lures and colors I didn't need. When he was younger, he bought every single lure and bait in every single color that caught his eye. He has over $15,000 of those lures, baits and colors that he never used and that sit in his garage gathering dust. Some of it is just that it's way too much for someone to use in their lifetime, (which is why I'm buying some of it!), but most of it is colors of baits that he found weren't as effective as others.
So, I figured that a discussion of basic, proven colors would help many members on here from buying tons of colors they don't need.
Here's his synopsis. He says that these colors are what 90% of the big names on the tours threw when he was fishing with them. no matter where they were fishing. These were the categories we discussed.
-Plastics and jigs:
No suprises here. Green Pumpkin and Black & Blue. (Excluding flukes/swimbaits/shad imitators and topwaters)
-Lipped Crankbaits: Blue with chartreuse sides (citrus shad), and some sort of plain shad imitator, such as sexy shad or the like.
-Lipless Crankbaits: Gold/Chrome, Blue/Chrome, and a Red/Orange.
-Spinnerbaits: Chatreuse/white, and white.
He didn't go through every category, but that sums a lot of baits up.
So, contribute your own thoughts, in particular if you've been fishing a long time.
If you had only two or three colors to fish for each category, which ones would see the water?
Soft Plastics (general)
Soft Plastics (shad imitators)
Soft Plastics (topwater)
Topwater
Lipless Cranks
Shallow/Medium Cranks
Deep Cranks
Jerkbaits
Jigs
Spinnerbaits
Buzzbaits
Chatterbaits
Frogs
Or, if you don't feel like going through the list, how 'bout a more general couple of colors or your favorite colors for a technique you've specialized in?
I'm not even going to pretend to know a lot in these categories-that's why I posted the thread. But, the more I fish, the more I find that the following colors work best:
-Plastics (general): Green Pumpkin, Black & Blue (or Junebug), and Black/Red
-Plastics (shad imitators): Pearl white, White/Blue back, and a bluegill imitator, such as Arkansas Shiner.
-Soft Plastics (topwater): Green Pumpkin, White
-Topwater: White, and a generic green. (Baby bass, Tennessee Shad)
-Lipless Cranks: Sexy Shad, Red
-Shallow/Medium Cranks: Sexy Shad, Bluegill, Chartreuse/Black Back
-Deep Cranks and Jerkbaits: I don't fish a lot.
-Jigs: Green Pumkin, Black/Blue, and Green Pumpkin/Chartreuse
-Spinnerbaits: Chartreuse/white
-Buzzbaits: Chartreuse/white
-Chatterbaits: Green Pumpkin (A lot of pros say this is the only color you need. I haven't tested out Black/Blue yet personally), chatreuse/white
-Frogs: White, Black, and Green
A discussion like this would have helped me back when I was starting my tackle collection, and I'm sure that if everybody pitches in, we can help beginners sort through color choices. Obviously, local colors have superstitious followers, like Margarita Mutilator in Cali, but let's focus on more general producers.
If ya'll decide to contribute, after the thread dies down, I'll synopsize the most voted colors for each category.
If I forgot a category, add it on lol .