I made the switch to braid main lines on everything the day I bought my first baitcaster earlier this year a few months after seriously getting into bass fishing. In my after-work fishing jaunts this past week, in which I've pretty much been throwing exclusively lipless crankbaits (with a few senkos on cleanup duty) I've lost a full 30% of my fish due to the lure being shaken free on a jump or whatnot. I figured this might have been because they weren't quite hooked that well, which, according to the textbooks, would be understandable, considering I'd been throwing them on some fairly stiff MH fast-action rods and 50lb braid.
On a whim, I strung up a spare reel I bought for a song with some 15lb Trilene Big Game and put it on the rod of my Black Max combo (I rarely use this rod anymore), a 6'6" "Medium Fast" (it's the slowest "fast" I've ever seen) in an attempt to make a "textbook" cranking setup out of whatever I had laying around. I figured that if anything, if I was getting a mix of decent and downright terrible hooksets with my preferred setups, I should practically be gut hooking every fish I land on this setup.
Boy, was I in for a shock. I have to admit, I've never fished a baitcaster on mono before. I made the jump to braid with my first baitcaster and never looked back. I felt like I had absolutely no feel of the lure, which was especially concerning because I was already throwing lipless crankbaits that d**n near rattled my arm off on braid. The only way I could tell that I had picked up some grass was that the lure seemed to be dragging just the tiniest bit more than before. Any ability I had to confidently rip out of grass was gone (although I'm sure some of that was attributable to the rod). I landed a couple of fish today but honestly it felt like I was trying to bring them in with surgical tubing. It was both more fun due to losing some of the ability to really direct the fish, giving me the perception that the fish was actually getting a chance to fight back some, but also massively frustrating since all of my inputs felt extremely dampened, from hookset to landing.
I'm also pretty sure that there's a fairly significant tradeoff between hookset delay and hookset power. I think that one can train themselves to hesitate before setting the hook, or learn to sweep-set (since I've been using braid from the beginning, I pretty much only sweep-set, if sometimes still pretty fast and hard), but there's just no way to compensate for loss of power, especially when setting the hook way out at the end of a cast.
Call me spoiled, but after today's experiments with fishing with mono, I don't think I'm ever going to leave braid as mainline. Good thing I got this spool of Big Game for only a dollar. I'm going to give this floppy Black Max combo rod another try tomorrow and see if using braid on a floppy rod gives me the best of both worlds solution I'm looking for.