You are spot on with your description of both, although I would call them "homers" more than puppets. It is almost comic relief with the two together, sometimes they start arguing about something on air & neither will give an inch. I met Hudler at a Down Syndrome fundraiser (he has a son with Downs as does a friend of mine) and he is the same bundle of self-deprecating energy in person as he is on the air. I don't think he ever got through reading a lineup card without tripping over himself, but he would always be the first person to laugh about it. When he was a player, he was being heckled by some fans who said something along the lines of "Hudler you suck". He went over to them and said "you guys are right, I can be horrible at times. I have no idea why they pay me to play". The fans were kind of stunned by the response & Hudler just kept doing what he does best, talking. in a matter of five minutes, he had won them over. He is the true definition of a people person and what you see is sincere. There is so much fakeness here in SoCal, I guess I really appreciated someone who is that real. It seemed like the players always liked him.
We have been lucky with announcers in this area, from Vin Scully to Chick Hearn to Dick Enberg & others. Over the years, I was getting so tired of East Coast bias on national broadcasts & ESPN that I find myself enjoying an announcer who is rooting for my home team. Kind of like having a buddy over to watch the game & announce at the same time.
Does Hudler still announce while holding on to the signed baseball from Ernie Harwell? He was so proud of that ball, almost as much as the World Series ring he got as an announcer. I hope he gets another one this year.