I really haven't spent much time fishing specifically for bedding bass, but I'm not opposed to it either. I have read probably 75% of this thread so far (I actually found this thread while searching the web for bedding bass research) and I have heard Studies mentioned but I haven't seen any sited. Can someone provide some links to show the actual studies themselves?
My thoughts on the subject have always been that a given body of water whether it be a lake or river can only support a certain number of mature fish. So take the 1:50,000 ratio of potential 3lb bass to eggs that was mentioned in an earlier post as a starting point. If there are 10,000,000 eggs laid during that year class you will have 200 fish that will reach 3lbs based on the ratio given as a starting point. Now, if there are several sight fishermen on this given body of water and as a result of them taking males off the nest and making the eggs vulnerable the nests in this given body of water lose1,000,000 eggs. Some would make the assumption that since there is a 1:50,000 survival ratio that this given body of water will lose 20 3lb bass from that year class. I tend to believe that this line of thinking is incorrect based on the ability for the given body of water to support a set number of mature fish. I don't believe the year class would lose 20 fish but that the survival ratio would change from 1:50,000 to 1:45,000.
Since a body of water has a limited number of resources to grow a limited number of fish that number will remain the same whether fish are taken off the beds or not. all that is gong to change is the survival ratio of the eggs that hatch.
If a given body of water has the ability to support 10,000 health mature fish but there happens to be 20,000 mature fish in the body of water, the fish won't be healthy. What needs to take place is an event that will decrease the total population of the fish in that given body of water back down to the 10,000 that it is capable of supporting. This could be a fish kill which would most likely take place naturally leaving the strongest fish alive. Or, some other form of regulation which would allow more smaller fish to be taken legally from the body of water so the larger fish wouldn't have to compete for the limited resources with the extra 10,000 fish giving them the opportunity to reach their potential.
I know I've read a study on this a few years back and unfortunanlty I haven't been able to locate it. Maybe there is someone here who will be able to post a link or two for some of these studies. I know most people find this type of thing a bore to read thru but I have always found it very fascinating!