Joe,
I have read some of your posts and feel like we might possibly be long lost brothers! I basically have the same questions/concerns that you have.
I did a lot of bank fishing a few years ago and thought I knew how to catch bass. Then last year (late July) I got a boat and have had very little success on the water since. It's like starting all over again. Anyway, I'm determined to have a good year and would like to "figure out" my local mud-puddle. To that end I have watched a bunch of videos and read a number of books, in particular the In-Fisherman books. When I think about what I did last year compared to what I have "researched" over the winter I think I was doing it all wrong. I watched what others were doing and mimicked their efforts and have little to show for it. So if I learned anything last year it is that just because someone say's they know how to catch fish or have a lot of nice gear, it doesn't mean that they really are good at this. I actually began to think that the lake I fish had no bass in it. But I read the state biologist report that was only a year old and watched a weigh-in from a tournament in the fall so I know there are bass in there. Some nice ones!
One of my friends fishes weekly summer tournaments on this lake, he has a partner and have been doing it for several years. Another mutual friend asked him if he knew anyone that might be interested in fishing the series, someone that has a boat. My friend suggested that he talk to me. Long story short, I've agreed to fish with this person. One of the problems is that I know more about bass fishing than my partner does and that's not saying much.
My plan is to get out on the water as soon as the ice melts and try to figure out where the fish are, then stay with them as the year progresses. I think the main problem I had last year is I thought I knew where they should be but I had no real evidence that they were actually there. I think I was fishing in the wrong place and so were others on the lake. Some of those others had very expensive boats and tackle.
I'm going to study the topo maps, read the weather, try to match colors and presentations and most important, try to locate the fish before I spend a lot of time trying to catch what might not actually be there. I also have to be a little less lazy, meaning I sometimes use the same lure or presentation that doesn't work only because I'm too lazy to change it. Also, I'm going to try to watch from a distance others at a few tournaments that will take place before I fish my first tourney. See how others do it.
And that's my plan.