It's all about odds to me. The baitball might boost your odds of catching by a fraction, maybe the opposite. But i believe that color, action and shape & design all change your odds. In my opinion, the subtleties like color and action of a lure, and in this case the baitball, all add up and its reflected in the number of fish you catch. I definitely believe some colors work better than others in particular bodies of water, but the percentages might be different by only a fraction of a fish being caught on a daily average.