Haha we must have a different strain of gar living here or something. I always hear about how aggressive they are, but the ones we have here are pretty smart. You have to make a stealthy approach, and a long cast way past them with a very good presentation (very small strike zone) to get them to eat. The fish I was catching when I caught the black one wouldn't eat a strip of cut bait but if you could get a bluegill about 3" long, kill it, and pop the swim bladder so it would sink, they would eat that if you twitched it right up to their nose and let it fall.
The only baits I have gotten gar to bite are hard jerkbaits, an s-waver 168, and last year I hooked a giant on my 6" bull shad but he threw it.
One of my biggest curiosities is what would happen if I made "feathered" trebles on my s-waver but use the nylon rope that gar get their teeth stuck in.