Well, like it or not, you should add soft plastics to the arsenal
I used to be EXACTLY like that as well. Just had no desired to fish soft plastics since it was just so slow. But there's no denying that they catch fish.
Anyway, here's a few suggestions:
1) Zoom trick worms -- a green/brown type color, and a dark color (junebug, black, purple)
2) Zoom finesse worms -- same colors as above. This is just a smaller version of the worm above.
These can be fished in a variety of ways. With a jighead, Texas style weighted or weightless, splitshot.
3) 5" Senkos -- watermelon or green pumpkin
Either Texas rig this one weightless, or wacky rig it. Look around for some more specifics on wacky rigging.
4) Zoom Super Flukes -- get a green/brown color and a baitfish color.
As far as the tackle to fish these, I'd recommend a pack of 2/0 and 3/0 EWG hooks -- these are usable for any of the presentations above. Also, get yourself some 1/16, 1/8 and 3/16 oz worm weights for the Texas rigs. Lastly, get some 1/16, 1/8 and 3/16 'bull shot' sinkers for splitshotting.
Also, try getting yourself a floating Rapala minnow.