I went out tonight to a spot that has been producing a steady frog bite with some quality fish. Tonight did not disappoint. This was a highly UN-scientific comparison, but it was fun!
I fished for about 2 hours total, starting at ~7:30pm. First up was the KVD Sexy Frog in the Spring Frog color. I went 1 for 4 on this one bringing in a nice 2.5lb. large mouth. I noticed with this frog the ones I missed felt like short strikes. On the one I did catch he hit it well and was hooked right in the top of the mouth. With this frog I was using a 7' MH Lightning Rod Shock, Shimano Citica with 50lb. Power Pro braid.
Second was the Spro Bronze Eye Jr. in the Rainforest Black color. I went 2 for 3 on this frog, Bringing in 2 fish both in the 2lb. range. The strikes on this frog were all aggressive. It seemed to hook the fish better than the KVD frog. With this frog I was using a 6'-6" M Lightning Rod (older model), Lew's Sped Spool with 14lb. Trilene XT green.
I suspect the better hook rate with the Spro frog was due to the softer action rod with the mono. I'm still trying to discipline myself to wait on the hook set, especially when using braided line. The one fish I did bring in on the KVD frog I purposely waited on the hook set. I'll be the first to admit in the difficulty in waiting after seeing the fish boil on the bait!
Both frogs had nice action and are very well built. Both have quality hooks in them and a drain hole for water. If the frog gets a little water logged just squeeze it, the water shoots out and you're good to go. I did trim the leg skirt material a 1/4" or so on the KVD frog as I felt it was a bit long.
Next test I'll switch frogs on each rod and will be adding the Booyah Pad Crasher in the Swamp Frog color.
Sorry, no pictures on this trip as I left it in the truck.....doh!