I think people have said this before, but you should try them out first hand before making a decision. For me, I feel way more comfortable with a left hand retrieve reel. I have 2 BPS PQ's and the lews speed spool. The PQ's have the dual braking system which helps but nothing is going to help you more than a well trained thumb. With that said, the lews speed spool just has the magnetic brakes, it's pretty light and it has a lower profile. Both reels are very smooth and if you can get one of them on sale, even better. Also figure that since the old man is helping you out, even if you pay full price, his advice and mentoring is well worth it.
Good luck, you can't go wrong with either reel.