In my opinion, you don’t have to be a great fisherman to be a good guide. If he knows the waters he’s guiding well enough to put clients on fish through the seasons, and he has the patience to teach newbies how to fish, he can be a good guide. But that’s only half of it. A guide has to be a people person. He has to put up with guests who know nothing about fishing and have never held a rod in their life and guys who think they know everything. If he goes into it thinking he’ll be able to fish everyday while getting paid, he might be in for a surprise. It might not be the norm everywhere, but in my experience, guides never fish while they are guiding. They may pick up a rod to demonstrate a technique, but that’s it. I know I pay the guide so I can catch fish not him. Guiding is a job. Day after day watching other people fish in all kinds of weather can be a grind. If he’s trying to make a living, pay his bills, put a kid through college and save for retirement, he probably will have a difficult time. If he’s trying to make a few extra bucks to make his boat payments, it is doable. I know guides who are great fishermen but have zero personality. They don’t get a lot of repeat business. Friendly guys who are fun to be around will do much better.