One topic that comes up frequently on other fishing forums that I don't recall seeing here has to do with posting specific fishing spots on an open forum. I see it done here but not very often. On a smallmouth forum where I am a moderator, we have rules prohibiting posting of exact locations. On our forums, most of our members fish small rivers and streams that could easily be hurt if a small river were hit by a lot of guys who just learned of a new hot spot. We saw a post about a warm water discharge where smallies would gather in the winter. The poster fished the spot, about the size of a pickup truck, frequently and almost never saw another angler. Soon after his post, there were as many as 8 guys fishing that same small spot on a Saturday morning. Guys who don't agree with our stance argue that there are no "secret" spots and that we should be helping our fellow anglers. That's a valid argument. But we are a conservation group and if we have to choose a side, we are going to side on protecting the fishery and respect those whose spots may not be secret, but may not be well know either. As a group, while we won't allow posts of exact locations on open forums, when we get together on the water, everyone shares information freely.
Here on Bass Resource, there are a wide variety of fishermen who fish everything from small ponds to the Great Lakes. There are a lot of lurkers around just waiting to take the easy way of finding fish. Is it OK to get that information here? I'd like to hear opinions from the pond fisherman, the tournament guys and anybody else who has an opinion about having someone post the location of exact fishing spots. I can see both sides of the issue. I can't say one way is right or wrong but that it may depend on the type of fishery being discussed.