This is so true! When I first started learning to fish I remember thinking that distance was the key to success for some reason. Meaning that if I can get the lure out the farthest then I somehow have a better chance of catching the fish. Length of time in the water ... bla, bla, bla.
As I observed my boater (I'm a co-angler) I noticed how short their casts are generally in compared to mine. As I learned about leverage and the "quality" of the cast vs. the quantity(length) my catch % grew exponentially.
Now there is a time and a place for long casts but it's the exception and NOT the rule. My go-to cast is far enough to keep control of my bait! With a spinnerbait it can be very long, with a shakey head not so much.
That results in a better presentation and thus more fish IMHO!