I have a Gen 3 Revo S and a Gen 3 STX. I had a Gen 2 SX which I HATED, and also own a Black Max 2 that uses the same braking system as the new SX. While the Mag Trax brakes are much easier to tune, I will never purchase another reel with magnetic only brakes. IMO, JUMP on the Revo S. It's a great reel, and it's buttery smooth. I can't say enough about it. I can launch baits like no other, and the pitch centrifugal brakes make back lashing nearly impossible. The S is available in only the 6:4:1 version, but it's plain amazing all around. If you want a great rod to stick it on, pair it up with a Veritas rod, which Walmart.com has on sale right now for $70.80 which is a STEAL. My vote goes to the S or STX if you have the extra cash.