I stopped by a small pond after work tonight that I had never seen before. It is right off the highway next to a baseball field. It is VERY small: I can cast from one side to the other width wise and lengthwise it is maybe 75 yards or so. It is very murky with only a few inches of visibility and LOTS of moss. I pulled over just to see if it had potential for fish and as I was walking around it, I saw a number of swirls indicating fish presence. My fishing poles are like American Express: NEVER leave home without them (my wife does not like this since we have a small car lol). I already had a weightless 5" green pumpkin senko rigged up so I tossed it in. I had a bite very quickly, but either the fish didn't commit, or I set the hook too hard too fast. And so this went on for a bit. In total, I had 4-5 good strikes in less than an hour, but I couldn't get the fish hooked. I did not see any fish jumping out if the water, but merely rolling. Usually indicative of carp, but carp would have no interest in a senko (would they?). I mean, when they would take the bait, I felt it tug and fight for a bit, but when I would set the hook, it was gone. One time I even whipped the senko right back at my face.
Question 1: should I try a smaller senko? I tried some cheap looking craw thing I had and got nothing. I tried texas rigging (with weight) the same senko and got nothing. I tried a T-rigged 7" finesse worm in green pumpkin with watermelon flakes and got nothing. I tried wacky rigging the same senko and got nothing. I tried a couple other colors and came up empty handed.
Question 2: does this sound like it could be a catfish? I've heard plenty of stories and seen a few videos of guys catching cats on senkos, so it doesn't seem too far fetched. Plus, I'm not certain how much fresh water flow is needed for bass. I know cats can live in just about any water though.
The reason I'm asking and not just trying it out is because I won't ever have much time to fish there; it will be an after-work-don't-let-the-wife-know trip (she's already on me about fishing too much and I barely get out that often). That, and I'm the rookies rookie. As I've said ad nauseam, I'm still learning this whole "catching" fish thing, let alone being able to feel bites. The sensitivity of braided line and a decent rod/reel is a whole new ball game for me. All that said, I'm not looking for answers for you all to tell me what exactly to fish; no, I still plan on going and just trying different techniques even if it means picking up some crawlers and slapping on a bobber lol. I would just like for some critique, perhaps.
If it helps, here are the google maps coords if you want to see the pond. 42.693388,-87.956838