Wow, this has gotten a lot more attention than I expected.
Okay, firstly let me say, that I understand the importance of accuracy. I truly do. That isn't the issue here, though.
This is in response to the same questioned posed on the bronco forum in which I spend most of my online life at... hah
anyway, a buddy of mine who does a lot of pond/lake fishing gave me a similar answer in that accuracy is more important than distance.
It appears that when I posed the question "what's a GOOD cast", that was interpreted by just about everyone, that I was inquiring towards what makes a good cast a good cast.
"let me put it this way, if most of the fish I've caught resided near the shore... I would have caught a FAKWTON of fish this month, last month, and the month before.
The reason I ask, is because everywhere I have gone lately, the fish have been well over 40' away from the shore WITH A LOT OF ACTION.
Take today for example. I went to a small lake that I'd never fished before with a buddy and we hit it hard. I saw a 4lb bass jump out of the water. And then about 20 2-4lb bass do the same. They were going nuts! But the action was so far away from me that I couldn't reach out & cast over them to retrieve them with my rod & reel.
Throwing 3/8 oz spinner with a 7' ugly stuck, on a shimano TX1200 (very old spinner) with like 15lb mono, and I'm falling about 10-12' short of where the action is, not even IN the action.
This is why I'm asking.
As some of you don't see this as relevant, or maybe even understand... I'm trying to cast over the fish & top water action to retrieve through it. I have had NO luck near shores with worms, top waters, cranks, or spinners. "
Most of, or 90% of my fishing is done standing on a shore. The shore in particular is a very shallow area. I have about 120-150 feet from the shore line to the boating channel. The depth of the water from the channel to the shore is about 3-4' deep in varying areas. You can watch the bass feed on the threadfin shad about 60-70' from the shore line. It's a rare occurrence when I can cast out far enough to land a bite. Usually when this happens, it's because I've lucked out and found a school of shad with hungry bass in tow closer to the shore. So it's critical for what I am doing to get more distance in my casts.
Now, I don't exactly know what 'load' means in terms of casting and my lure, but I'm presuming this is the curve of the rod as I rare-back and begin my cast. If that is the case, I have great load on my two spinning rods, and not so much on my casting rod.
I don't understand why you say 14lb mono is too large for spinning reels? I have an old quantum that dwarfs my shimano, it currently has no line on it and doesn't get used much because the bail does not automatically flip back down when you begin to retrieve. I have to manually close it.
The shimano has a fairly 'deep' spool for it's size of reel, and it's one of the larger ones from it's generation.
I may have mentioned this in the forum before, but this is a hobby to me. I refuse to spend hundreds upon hundreds of dollars on tackle. That's just silly. If I wanted to spend stupid money on a hobby, I would go back to offroading and repairing/replacing broken junk on my Bronco. I thank you all for your input in telling me to go to 'better' equipment or better line, but I don't see the sense in spending a great deal of money on it.
With that said, the tackle/equipment is what I've got, and that isn't going to change. I am interested in buying fireline for my smallest combo (the stampede reel) and testing it that way. Probably with 20lb fireline. And if I like it, I will spool the rest of my reels with it.
So, I have included a few pictures to show you what I'm using, maybe this will end the confusion of what rod/reel I have. Most of you are pretty well aware of current market stuff, but since mine is a decade or more older, you may not be as familiar with it.
As you see, I use the shimano & ugly stik for spinners and cranks. It works well for that.
I use the 5500C for cranks, spinners, and heavier baits as (in my head) it's the strongest combo I have.
And the Stampede/IM6 is for great for worms, small spinners, and 1/8-1/4 lipless cranks.
I don't own anything larger than 1/2 oz, unless that bigàss crank you see in the picture is 3/4 (I found that one floating on a rocky shore)
So most of what I throw is 1/8, 1/4, & 3/8. I have two 1/2 lures that I rarely throw.
I hope this sheds some light on what I'm inquiring about and what's going on. I didn't mean for it to turn into something complicated with left-right-upside down replies.
Basically, I'm just asking "Hey, why isn't my gear casting as far as other people's gear" if the answer is as simple as "Your gear is old and sucks", well that's just that. And I can live with that.