I think it could have been a where you placed your lure at that moment and what that fish were feeling that day type of thing.
Plastics I usually use white, black or green. I have a lot to go threw and pink yellow or any bright color isn't in the rotation right now.
I don't think I own any green Hardbaits. They are white, black, and a variation of crawfish or baitfish.
I think it's more a time and place situation.