Matt I 've always said: the wrong lure in the right hands outfishes the right lure in the wrong hands.
Catching fish is as much science as it is art, some anglers are "talented" by nature, mother nature has provided them with all they need to catch fish, in them catching fish is a second nature, they are natural fishermen just as there are natural players in football or baseball, there 's somthing in them that makes them shine over the rest of the crowd, but people like them are the smallest population.
Most anglers are not "talented", most anglers need to "learn" how to catch fish, they must learn how to select baits, how to work them properly, how to read the water, how to cast properly and accurately, etc.. Some learn better, faster and practice more than others, practice makes perfect.
The artistic part of fishing comes into play when you may know all the technical data about lures, conditions, etc., but everybody is different, each of us imparts it 's own personality to the lures,you are the one that makes the bait work, and it 's not the same being fishing for 20 years, you may have 1 year experience multiplied by 20 than having 20 years "experience".