We all have pretty much the same baits in our T-boxes, we all have cranks, spinnerbaits, soft plastics, jigs and such, we all have the same tools.
The principle here is: as long as the bait moves like if it 's alive and an easy prey a predatory fish will attack it, it doesn 't matter if it looks or mimics something natural, it only matters if it behaves like if it 's alive and an easy prey.
So think of fishing like cooking, you have the ingredients of the recipe ( your lures ), you have the recipe, you may follow the recipe step by step but that doesn 't mean you 'll make a great dish, what makes a great dish and what differentiates a regular cook from a great chef are not the ingredients nor the recipe, it 's how those ingredientes are mixed together.
Will you catch fish with "unnatural" baits ?
Absolutely !
So where 's the catch ?
Where it has always been ----> it 's in the chef where the magic is, behind the rod handle.
Don 't overthink it, keep it simple !