As for sheer numbers of quality smallies, I wouldnt put any lake over Erie or St. Clair. I would however, put Simcoe over both of them for numbers of BIG fish.
Fish on left is 7-0, right is 5.5
My fiancees first 7
Not a good pic, but this was a 7-2
Left was a 6-11
Not quite 7, but close, tank for mid-summer
I'll try and scrape up some more pics.