Ive got the Curado I and Tatula R, the Curado is the longer caster for me, but other than that, they are very similar in performance in most other respects. But what sways it for the Curado is the palming. Its almost 50 sized which is a huge plus for me for the way I palm, I have to change my grip with the Tatula because the teeth on the mag dial rubs my finger raw. Id go to a BPS and handle them both, put them on a rod and see what feels best.