you have to try to use different techniques...also the weather,water-temp,and clarity of the water are a big role on what to throw into the water... a roster tail is always a good way to start out on a new pond also go with more natural colors such as: watermelon seen,pumpkinseed,junebug,and if your state regs let you try and hook a bream in the back with a big cork and see if you have any luck.