Without knowing the lake well why Rogers? Eureka has tons of great hotels or cabins and beautifull scenery and killer restaurants. We've been going to Eureka for years. We've stayed at a place called Thurmans Lodge a few times. It's about $50 and we could park In front of our room and run a cord out to charge our boats.
If staying in Eureka is an option I'd change my vote to Beaver in a minute!