Each angler is different when it comes to versatility. Are there lures or presentations that KVD hasn't mastered or refuses to learn? Many like him were power fishermen and slowing down meant less fish until not slowing down nor using a slower presentation meant less fish. Not too many who've posted this topic are in a Clunn or KVD class and most likely will never be given the many factors that limit us. Here are a few:
1. You and I can read every article written on a certain presentation or lure, but unless we've seen someone in the same boat clobber fish with it, we are less inclined to use it or after trying it unsuccessfully, ever try it again much less master it. Seeing is (sometimes) believing (except on TV).
2. Many of us don't have the time or resources to fish many different waters where certain presentations do well with certain lures at different times of year or a different time of day. Again, we can read until the cows come home what the winners used to win a tournament on lake X, but until we fish that water or one very similar, under those conditions, you or I will be at a loss why the lure or presentation didn't work where we normally fish. Ever fish a lake only once in the year because the club had a tournament there? Not knowing a body of water is like not knowing when or where to use certain lures - you won't go back there and in the back of your mind believe the lake stinks because you couldn't get a bite. I know a group of guys from my club that fished a Red Man open tournament down south and skunked miserably. These guys were the best at fishing waters the club fished but not as versatile as they thought on strange water in a different state.
3. Strong beliefs and prejudices limit the confidence needed to believe in a lure or presentation and they are due to 1. and 2. as well as financial considerations to justify even owning a variety of lures and colors. One size does not fit all - not one lure size, not one color, not one lure action nor at all speeds nor at all depths. Disappointment and frustration kills confidence in lures and presentations when we don't follow that simple rule. As has been stated many times before, there is a time and a place that certain group of tools of the trade are called for and many of those tools are put to better use by others who have overcome a whiff of prejudice against using them.
The strangest thing of all is when I've logged having caught many fish on certain lures in the past and then packed them away, completely forgetting them or their successes. I have a tendency to mistakenly believe that a lure that did well the first year or so, will not do well from then on - anywhere. So much for keeping an open mind and not substituting the new for the old. Which brings me to:
4. Embracing the fad --- or fear of it
How many have completely substituted lures and presentations for new ones? We live in a disposable society so for many that's the norm. On the other hand how many fad lures come and go and it makes us skeptical every time a new one comes out. Sure, the A rig works in some waters for some anglers, but we automatically suspect the lure is far less versatile than some we already own. Same for the Chatterbait or the similar action of Helin's Flat Fish crank bait. Why would we buy a new lure that obviously only works in a brief period of the year or day? Was it promoted by someone that we no longer trust? Again, the tendency is to buy a one size does not fits all lure or never give it a chance.
5. Lastly, how many of you pack a ton of lures every time you go fishing only to use maybe a hand full. Many anglers I know carry hundreds of lures, many full packs of soft plastics, boxes of spinnerbaits, jigs and crankbaits, yet few get wet anytime. I think some believe that carrying more is better, not realizing that more is just plain confusing and limiting to those that don't know how and when to use the majority of what they own. I witnessed that frustration with a tournament partner I fished with. In two days I caught far more than he did with the small selection I carried versus the large box of lures he never used except for one or two. Not once did he look at the sonar or ask questions and therefore never knew what I was casting to. My lures were never adopted by him even though he owned them and worse, he refused to use them after
three fish were caught within fifteen minutes!
A closed mind is such a waste and much of the time self defeating.