The biggests Smallie I've ever caught was 7.04 lbs!!!!
May 2002 - Mellinium Bassmaters "Make a Wish" Charity tourney out of Buffalo NY.
Sad thing was.... with over 75 boats in the tourney, it was not the biggest one caught! It was 2nd largest caught in the tourney ( if you can believe that!) the largest was 7.35 lbs caught by another boat.. anyway, the tourney actually gave prizes down to 2nd biggest fish so I lucked out anyway ( my partner and I had a 2 fish weight of 12.98lbs and finished 6th place, just out of the big money )
Erie produces fantastic Smallies in may, Myself as well as many guys in our club have caught countless 6+ lbs, you can catch 5+ with little effort in early spring and late fall
basic tube draggin/hoppin, in 25-30 feet structure, color varies, but I usually use smoke with some red and black fleck
Al Gorrie
Niagara Bassmasters