Wow a 2 page thread about the Chiefs and only one Chiefs (now 2) have chimed in.
Personally I think we gave up too much. I even thought it was too much when we were rumored to be giving up a 4th when the rumors started around and after the Superbowl. Now a high high second this year and potentially a second next year?!?!!?! Advantage 49ers.
My problem isn't so much with Smith himself. I think he is a descent QB. Middle of the road if you will. In my opinion the Chiefs already had that in Cassel. Yes the last couple years have been awful, but he put up good #s with the Patriots and with the Chiefs when we had Charlie Weis as the OC. The KC coaching staff, especially on the offensive side of the ball, has been a train wreck. I think Cassel has proven that as long as he has a good coaching staff in place (which I think we have now) he can put up pretty good #s.
Career Numbers: Alex Smith- 81 Tds, 63 Ints, 79.1 QBR, 59.3% cmp Matt Cassel- 82 Tds, 57 Ints, 80.4 QBR, 58.9%
Overall I am just sick of the QB approach from the Chiefs in my lifetime. We've always had "game managers". Other teams back ups. They don't even attempt to draft and develop a stud QB anymore.
For you non-KC fans or followers think about this .... The Chiefs have not won a game with a QB they drafted since 1987.
I am not saying that stud QB is in this draft, but this trade I think seals the deal that we will be going with Smith for the foreseeable future. I would have rather seen us keep Cassel and the picks and try and find and develop a QB. And keep picking them until you find one.
I hope I am dead wrong.