I like this thread a lot. I think I agree with needemp: There are times when a very specific lure-with size, speed, action, depth, color, soft, hard, seasoned or not, and probably several other variables to define-is the one.
My trouble is I can spend way too much looking for that one, instead of keying on the 3 or 4 techniques I know work for me. Then again sometimes I spend way too much time experimenting within the confines of proven techniques instead of looking for that one bait that may be outside of my favorites. :-? :
So my philosophy today (it may be different next week) is to have a lot of what works for me and a little of everything else. I just wish I knew what, "a little" "a lot " and "everything else" meant exactly? :-/