Why would you dislike bowfishing just because it kills the fish? Standard fishing techniques kill fish sometimes and lots of people at least occasionally keep the fish they catch to eat, even bass. I have a list of people I can call that are more than happy to eat the fish I shoot, carp, buffalo, gar, drum, doesn't matter what. They're people with very low incomes that might not eat otherwise. There's a reason states allow bowfishing for the fish species they do, very few people fish for and eat rough fish like carp and buffalo. These fish also grow quickly therefore becoming to large for control by other predators. Even on lakes that I bowfish a lot and that get lots of pressure from other bowfisherman the populations of rough fish are out of control, to the point that the state has started shocking and netting the lake just to try to curb the population a little. There has to be some kind of population control just like there is with other "gamefish". If you don't keep some bass from a lake they will become overpopulated and eventually you'll run into a fishkill because there isn't enough food or a diesease kills off all the unhealthy fish. I enjoy catching carp and gar almost as much as bass fishing and sight fishing drum is a real challenge and a lot of fun so it's not like I think they are just trash fish that should be killed at all costs. It's also a real challenge that gets me ready for bow season for deer and is not even close to "shooting fish in a barrel". I'm sorry I'm ranting a little bit but it seems like there are lots of people who don't like bowfishing and I can't ever get an answer that my tiny brain can make sense of I guess.