While the OP pointed out some specifics about the Lews reel he either did not like, did not make sense to him, or were of poor quality, like others I would not consider this a review simply because there was no on-the-water evaluation. It was simply a long list of opinions on qualities of the Lews reel (by purely looking at it) that conflicted with what he liked about a Shimano. No problem. Each of us has our preferences in what makes for a good/great reel and which reels we do not like. What one individual likes in a reel may not be the same as someone else. The thing is maybe all those additional bearings and other features that weren't liked have a reason and purpose and perhaps, after actually using the reel, he may feel different. But, he'll never know because he's already eliminated it as a possible purchase. I have no problem with his decision because the truth is, most of us make a reel purchase in a very similar judgemental and even biased manner.
The Lews clearly did not fit the criteria the OP likes in a reel. But, like with any other piece of equipment that is commented on within this forum, his opinion should not be the final word on the quality or performance of the reel. Let each be their own judge. I have just ordered a Lews Tournament (not the pro) Speed Spool to replace a reel I never really liked. Whether or not I like the Lews reel once it's put through its paces is unknown until I try it. But, I can't stand my current reel and needed a replacement. I reasoned that the Lews was a logical choice based on so many positive comments. I'll soon see if it was worth it.