Hmm seems like rational comments giving ones personal point of view.
Being called out as a kid really reflects on the person making that comment and shows who the real fanboy might be, not being able to handle different opinions of a product.
These are the same rods that had all the breakage issues, it might have been fixed but still many breakage issues, for every good comment posting I can find a post of a broken veritas.
I think many products are over-hyped thats just natural to make ones self feel better of the things they have.