Breaking this down one at a time , cool or cold water , spinners and or blade baits are a good cool or cold water , decent choice , but where you made the mistake was with the silver willow leaf blade , good for clear water and or bright sunny days , lots of flash , the Colorado blade would have been a much better choice , Colorado blades are great for vibration type situations , dark , stained waters , the chrome colored rattle trap , the same , bright sunny conditions , would have chosen more of a shad pattern under your conditions .
Need more info on water color and condition , I'm with CWB , you did not mention where the strike came from , a grass line ( break ) etc ... Note everything and ask again , but suggestions as of right now would be a Texas rigged worm , or lizard worked slowly on the bottom , this is the SUV rig that pretty much and for the most part works for just about everything .
Good luck and be safe !!!