Is that Lake Mendota? HMMM I would try over by the spill way where the pavillion is on the BACK side along lake drive... not long where Parkway is... but then again I would try all along that side too, I think that is the deepest part of the lake... I haven't ever caught anything bigger than what you caught out there either, I just wanted to stomp the stuffing out of the dang ducks there, but I would go with a trick worm or a texas rigged zoom worm on a #2 EWG with the LIGHTEST weight you can find... But if I were you I would just go to Lake Kakusha? Is that what its named? THE ONE BEHIND the little lake... My nephew caught a sweet 5 pounder out of there years ago... I don't know where to tell you to go anymore. I left Mendota YEARS AND YEARS ago, I graduated from MHS in 84... Everytime I come home I will always go to the lake and wet a hook. Go to Ace Hardware and take a look at their tackle.. they are a BPS "outlet" they don't have much but that is about all you have to pick from... and NO ONE there knows anything about fishing... Maybe you can go to the bait shop over by to viaduct to where the OLD HS used to be... I can't remember the name... and while your at it.... stop at Ziggys and get me a double breaded cheeseburger deluxe... you have NO IDEA how much I am craving one of those....
let me know how it goes...
PS I have family that still live in Mendota.