I want to start by saying this review is JUST for the Pit Boss. I haven't tried all the Havoc baits; only the Pit Boss and the Craw Fatty. IMO the Craw Fatty is garbage. It's really no different, and in many ways worse than, a Sweet Beaver. That said - the PIT BOSS IS AWESOME.
Bought a few packs of PIT BOSSES for the reasonable price of $2.99/pack. Couldn't be more impressed. Fished a weekend on my local lake where the water is high enough to cover the shoreline brush. The first morning I had 15+ lbs in the boat within 2 hours (best 5 fish). That's pretty darn good on this lake. The rest of the weekend 90% of my keepers came on these when other baits were failing miserably.
The action is dead on. There are 4 appendages; the middle 2 have no action, the outer 2 flutter or swim. The body is thick and there is a gap in the middle to accommodate the hook point. You can effectively 'skin' the hook point inside the little ridge and still remain completely snag free. Great design. The swimming action seems to be just the right amount - not too much action but more than a beaver-style bait. When flipped on a 3/8oz or 1/2oz pegged weight the falling/swimming action is a dead-on bluegill imitator. The result is some seriously violent strikes on the fall.
Overall I'm really, really impressed with this bait. The design is perfect in all ways and more importantly it really catches even when other soft plastics are not getting bit. And, in a time when all the other guys are INCREASING their price per pack (I'm looking at you YUM and Strike King), these are introduced at $3. Great value, superior design, great bait.