Ha, yes I guess I should have specified the Full moon on the Sun comparison, the New moon phase isn't very sun-like
When I quoted you before, I was talking about using the same baits as daytime, I think everyone tends to go out and focus on topwater only, black only, big baits, all of those stereotypical things associated w night fishing. My point was, my interpretation of what you mean by fishing the same baits regardless of night/or day, is that you just go fishing and react to the conditions the way we are all supposed to do...You're not trying to reinvent the wheel at night. AKA, if the weather moves in during the day or night, it causes the fish to change, if it gets bright and calm during the day or night, it causes a similar reaction, etc..You don't just go out and say, "well, the suns down, throw a big topwater all night!!" (which is to some extent what I've been doing a lot of the time, and a lot of the time it works, just not always).
I'm agreeing totally on the topwater analysis, now I've just got to start "going fishing" at night on those brighter/calmer periods!
Although not mentioned, the Jerks (Floaters, wakers, and countdowns) and Traps are absolutely a big part of my arsenal, although I haven't been using them at night during the last year. Deep cranks are tough for me from the bank though.
I had committed to the topwater thing because I wanted to be able to go back and make an across the board comparison to all of these ponds I've been fishing for the last year, and I felt like limiting the bait selection as much as possible, at least for the night fishing trips, would help me to make a more consistent evaluation. I was new to the numerous local ponds because I had always boat fished and also pretty green at night fishing in general a year ago, so I felt like "sacrificing" the first year or so would be a great way to build up a large fishing log covering as many different ponds, water colors, weather situations, pond types, seasonal patterns, etc. as possible.
I've learned a lot from the experience, but although I have always entered the moon data for each trip, it never really occurred to me to look at the moon just at face value (bright/dark/rise/set), rather than through the lens of the solunar charts...so thanks again to you three for bringing it up in A-Jays thread!!
Lessons Learned: No guarantee of a topwater bite at night, only no sunburns!!