I use both. I just switched from a baitcaster to spinning for jig fishing, not because of the reel but because of the rod. I have a 6'6" Avid MH spinning that I decided to try a jig on. Well, the first day I was really sticking the jig in the bass. When using my Dobyns 683C casting setup I was not getting the hookset and losing fish. So, sometimes it is the rod you will feel comfortable with. When fishing moving baits, cranks and s/b's, I like the control of a baitcaster. If you try both, I think you'll agree a baitcaster is the way to go. I use spinning for small plastics, senkos, grubs, tubes and any weightless plastics I may put on. Topwater baits usually go on my baitcaster but sometimes I'll use a spinning setup with a lighter bait like a Rebel Pop R.