I've used a variety of nets. None rubber ... yet. I've currently got a collapsible net from Walmart, believe Frabil makes it. Small, extends far enough, and I'm only out $12 if it gets lost.
Last net I had, similar to this one, one of my boys tossed it to me in a moment of need, but didn't use enough arm in the throw, and it sank, just out of reach.
I do like the ego nets. Guess I need to get one that floats and forget about the cost.