I've become a big fan of Shimano, especially their
baitcasters.
Got 2 Stradic 1000 FI reels and 2 Chronarch 50e
reels. The 50e reels are absolutely amazing. I really
like the Stradics -- a lot. They're light and fully capable
of reeling in 6+ pound bass with nary a hitch.
The Smokes I've only heard about in reviews and such.
I'm sure they're great reels, and light. But when I went
in to BPS to buy spinning reels I left with the Stradic.
Something about the quality, the feel, etc. Haven't been
disappointed. The Quantums felt like solid reels but
something drew me to the Shimano reels. I also like
Daiwa.
But If you are flipping a coin, good luck. For me, I'd pick
the Shimano.