First, welcome to the forums!
Second, it is hard to go wrong (IMHO) with
Shimano. I absolutely love my Chronarch 50e
reels.
But there are plenty here that will sound off in
the positive about Diawa's Tatula reels, Lew's
reels, Quantum, and others.
So my best advice, if it is possible for you, is to
head to your local Bass Pro -- or if other sporting
goods store call and ask if they do this -- and take
your rod(s) in and ask to try several different reels
on them to see how they balance out and "feel"
to your hands.
I may love Shimano and sing their praises, but you
might take a deeper liking to a Pflueger, or a Diawa.