I bought one to throw on my local river. I throw a bomber in sexy shad color and have very successful outings catching sauger, smallmouth, largemouth, white bass, flatheads and an occasional walleye. I have thrown the flicker shad every outing and have yet to get a strike. It runs true, looks good, but i have yet to catch a fish. And thats how i judge a bait. Iv talked to guys at the boat ramp and thats all they use to troll for sauger and walleye. So i guys one mans trash is another mans treasure.