Something happened 6 years ago that made me go from a person who hated tubes, to someone who had to try. For the last 6 years I have committed myself to tubes. Going so far as to buying a tube mold and customizing my own to my liking for the technique I would be using them for. Even won AOY in my club last year, and I'd say 90% of my fish came on a 3.5 inch tube. I used to think a jig was the most versatile bait in the bass fishing world, and I still love jig fishing. Now, i would say with great confidence it is a tube. Here are several ways I fish a tube.
Carolina Rig: My favorite way to Carolina rig a tube is with spinning tackle. First, I put on a bobber stop, then a 1/8 oz tungsten, and then another bobber stop. This allows me to change "leader" length on the fly, without retying. I dont inject my tubes with salt, so it helps them suspend. Or, take a piece of foam earplug, stuff inside the tube. This allows the tube to suspend above vegetation, or above rock or whatever structure you are fishing.
Texas Rig: I believe there is no wrong way to fish a tube on a texas rig. I've caught fish punching a tube with a 1 ounce weight, to skipping docks with a texas rig tube on a 1/16 oz tungsten.
Jig head: I prefer the jigs that insert into the tube. but a simple painted jig head from your local wal mart will get the job done if need be. This is a rig I like to use up north in michigan for smallies. It's not nearly as effective here in illinois because most of the cover I fish is vegetation, docks, and rip rap. Occasionally I will use this technique on deep points when they stop chomping on a Carolina rig or jig.
Hook:I strictly use a Trokar Tube hook. It's a beefier hook than most of the tube hooks out there, but I can negate that extra weight by inserting a ear plug in the tube to suspend it if that's goal. The keeper holds a tube on better than any other hook I have tried. Not pushing a product, it's just my favorite hook for tube fishing.
Colors: I have tried hundreds of different colors, and own hundreds of colors. In the end, I only need two. Green pumpkin, and some short of shad color (most manufacturers make a Smoke color).I like a little orange glitter in my green pumpkin, but it's all personal preference. I have had some great days on a Junebug tube as well. Just like any bait, color is a confidence thing. But a shad or smoke colored tube on the Carolina rig I mentioned above can be deadly. Its tossed the skunk out of the boat countless times.
Size: I throw 3 sizes. 2.75 inch, 3.5 inch, and 4 inch. 3.5 inch is by far my best producer, but I also throw it the most. I use the small 2.75 for jig heads sometimes, and the 4 inch for flipping on a t rig. The 3.5 does everything for me though. If I am flipping wood. A lot of times I'll flip a jig and creature bait, but there is always a 3.5 or 4 inch tube on deck as well.
Style: not all tubes are the same. Some are double dipped, some are loaded with salt, some are soft, some are hard. Some are dipped with one color, and then redipped for a two colored tail. for instance, a BPS 3.5 Tender Tube is very slim compared to a Strike King coffee tube. Which tubes you throw where is completely up to what you have confidence in. I prefer a slim tube compared to a double dip, but there are guys who swear by a double dip thick body tube. In my little experience, the slender profile gets more bites. I'm not saying it's better than double dip, it's just what I have confidence in.
I have yet to try the "stupid" tube yet, but i already have that on my to do list. If anyone else would like to add to this, feel free. But if you are an angler who wants to try a versatile bait, the tube should be in your boat or tackle box. Thanks and tight lines.